Tony Pieper

We’re still reeling from the announcement that Tony Pieper and Blakeley Jones are over, but should we have seen it earlier? Two weeks ago, Tony posted the above pic to his Instagram with the caption: “Working on getting back to show shape!! Time to step it up! #motivated.”

Show shape, huh? That couldn’t possibly mean Tony is planning on diving back in the hot tub for...

By now, we’ve returned our wedding presents for Tony Pieper and Blakeley Jones (it was his and hers Carhart jackets, FYI) and have disbanded our “life for Bachelor Nation couples is completely unfair” poetry group.

As you may recall, the beautiful cocktail waitress and feelings-rich lumber salesman found love in the hopeless place that is Bachelor Pad 3. Turns out, BP3...