Credit: Bill Records/ABC Family Photo: Sutton and Thayer Look Dismayed in Season 1, Episode 3: “Double Dibs”

The Lying Game is chock full of so many dramatic twists and turns that we’re practically heaving into a paper bag by the end of every episode. Check out the 5 biggest OMG moments from “Double Dibs” — and yes, Ethan’s (Blair Redford) shirtless man beauty topped the list!

5. Emma and Ethan almost kiss

Emma’s (Alexander Chando) turning out to be the worst long-lost twin sister ever. First she broke up with Sutton’s (Alexander Chando) fake boyfriend, then she came out of the secret-relationship closet with Sutton’s real boyfriend, and now she’s trying to make out with him. Sigh, get a grip girlfriend! Emma and Ethan came within centimeters of swapping spit, and we have a feeling it’s only a matter of time before they lock lips for real.

4. Mads makes out with Eduardo

Clearly, Mads (Alice Greczyn) has watched Dirty Dancing one too many times, because her private lessons with Eduardo just went from PG to PG-13! Will they take their student-teacher relationship the next level of inappropriate, or will Eduardo reject Mads’ sexy moves? Either way, we fear the wrath of Daddy Rybak (Adrian Pasdar). First he takes computers, then he takes lives.

3. Mr. Rybak takes a trip to The City of Angels

How long does it take to get from Phoenix to L.A, because one minute Alec was playing golf with Ted (Andy Buckley) and the next he was peeking into Sutton’s window like a first-class creeper. Doesn’t this hunk have anything better to do with his time than spy on pretty twins?

2. Sutton and Thayer have a sleep over

Did anyone else sense the sexual tension between Sutton and Thayer? This girl might have just dropped the L-word on Ethan, but it’s not like she’s never had two simultaneous boyfriends before. We have a sneaking suspicious that Sutton and Thayer are going to end up all over each other before her trip to California is dunzo. Oh well, now Ethan won’t have to feel guilty about hooking up with Emma!

1. Ethan goes shirtless

Why, who’s that Greek God resting on those dirty sheets? Oh, it’s just Ethan, doing his studly thang. We don’t know how this boy finds time to work out in between fixing motorcycles and moon-gazing, but we’re not complaining. Let’s just hope this isn’t the last time Ethan takes his shirt off for no apparent reason, because OMFG!