Credit: ABC Family Photo: Emma Looks at Sutton in The Lying Game Season 1, Episode 10: “East of Emma”

At the end of The Lying Game Season 1 finale, we had far more questions than answers: Where did Annie Hobbes get that hoodie? What did Alec (Adrian Pasdar) get Sutton (Alexandra Chando) for her birthday? Who was the in the back of Sutton’s car? And most importantly, is Sutton really dead?

Basically, we have no idea. The car was filling up with water pretty fast and all we heard was some gurgling sounds. We know Sutts has a wicked backhand on the tennis court, but is she certified in swimming? Do we seriously have to wait until January 2012 to find out?

Need your daily dose of The Lying Game? “Like" us on our Facebook page at facebook.com/The LyingGameFansite, or follow us on Twitter at twitter.com/TLGWetpaint!