Credit: Felicia Graham/ABCFamily Channel © 2012 Disney ABC Television Group Photo: Ethan Behind Bars in The Lying Game Season 1, Episode 18: “Not Guilty as Charged”

It’s not that we’re excusing Ethan’s (Blair Redford) actions from The Lying Game Season 1, Episode 17, “No Country for Young Love.” But the poor boy has an ex-girlfriend, Sutton, who looks exactly like his current one, Emma (Alexandra Chando). This is why you shouldn’t date twins!

Even Blair Redford was defending Ethan on Twitter: “You guys are cracking me up with these ‘hate tweets’. I'm sorry, I'm sorry! Young Ethan was under a great deal of stress I tell you!” Stress — and the influence of a sexy fireplace. Oh, Ethan. In Season 1, Episode 18, “Not Guilty as Charged,” Ethan and Emma will come face to face for the first time since he got nearly naked with Sutton. Do you think she should forgive her bf for cheating or ditch him like her old wardrobe?