Credit: Bill Records/ABC Family Photo: Derek Converses With Alec Rybak in Season 1, Episode 3: “Double Dibs”

Things were pretty cozy on The Lying Game for awhile. Sure, Sutton (Alexandra Chando) ruined her favorite Manolos nearly drowning in that lake, but overall the twins’ biggest problem was coordinating their bedazzled band-aids with their party dresses. Then suddenly Derek’s (Ben Elliott) dead, Ethan’s (Blair Redford) the prime suspect, and Mads’ dad (Adrian Pasdar) has a girlfriend (whose possibly more evil than he is!). All of Phoenix is topsy-turvy, and those beautifully wrapped Lying Game packages seem much more sinister.

Whoever killed Derek was probably the person who told him to hide in Sutton’s car. He and Alec were chummy the whole season, so he’s the obvious choice, but something tells us it can’t be wrapped up so easily.