Credit: Bill Records/ABC Family Photo: Thayer, Char, and Sutton Look Intense in Season 1, Episode 7: “Escape From Sutton Island”

Emma (Alexandra Chando) has an unfortunate habit of stealing Sutton’s boyfriends (along with everything else in her life), and we have a feeling Thayer’s (Christian Alexander) next on her hit-that list. Did you see the way Em was swooning over this nerd’s detective skills? She could barely contain herself! And it looks like Thayer returns the favor — he even told Ethan (Blair Redford) that Emma was just like Sutton.

We have a sneaking suspicion that the love triangle between Emma, Ethan, and Sutton just turned into a love square. Welcome to the party, Thay — hope you brought your right hook!