Title: O Twin, Where Art Thou
Air Date: January 2, 2012 at 9:00 PM PST
While Ethan and Emma were partying the night away at her 17th birthday party, Sutton’s car was sinking to the bottom of a lake. The police pull the car out, and Thayer starts accusing Ethan of dastardly deeds. Char is excited to see her aunt, but no one else is pleased she’s returned to Phoenix.