Title: Twinsense and Sensibility
Air Date: September 5, 2011 at 9:00 PM PDT
Emma discovers that the nightmare she’s been having is the exact same one Sutton has been having for years. Sutton wants Emma to recall every detail she can about their birth mother, but it takes a nighttime encounter with Ethan for her to start remembering anything. Using these small clues, Sutton tracks down the house where her mother and Emma lived for a time. There, Sutton uncovers some information that has been deliberately kept from her, putting her life in danger.
With Sutton looking for information, Emma focuses on convincing Ted that Ethan isn’t guilty of stealing the laptop. Ted seems evasive and guilty, and Emma believes he’s hiding something about their birth mother.