Title: Bad Boys Break Hearts
Air Date: September 19, 2011 at 8:00 PM PDT
Still thirsting for revenge after spying pictures of Emma and Ethan kissing at homecoming, Sutton ends up hurting Thayer, whom she has been able to rely on until now. Instead of patching things up with him, Sutton forces herself to stay focused on finding Annie Hobbes.
Emma starts trying to track down her birth mother from Arizona, which puts not only her secret identity at risk, but people’s lives as well.
Laurel’s loving the change in Sutton’s attitude and falling for her new boyfriend, Justin. Not everyone is charmed by him, though; Kristin thinks there’s something strange about Justin’s family situation. At first Laurel isn’t suspicious, but she begins to have doubts about the guy who seems so perfect.