Title: Episode 2, Season 3: Advantage Sutton
Air Date: January 22, 2013 at 9:00 PM PST
Sutton decides she wants her life back, and challenges Emma to a winner-takes-all game of tennis to determine who gets to live as Sutton. To keep Ethan from failing out of school, Emma begins tutoring him. Meanwhile, Laurel asks Jordan out on a date, and a break occurs in Alec's murder case.