Teenaged witch Davina Claire (Danielle Campbell) has been a bit of a wild card thus far on The Originals. She’s really the only character who has any hopes of challenging the Original family’s dominance, but she is also somewhat unsure about who she should trust or betray. The news that Davina is about the make a “life-altering choice” has us scrambling to make sense of this unpredictable character. What choice is Davina about to make?

To complete the Harvest

According to executive producer Julie Plec, upcoming episodes will feature “a big move in the witch community, a life-altering choice made for Davina, and an attempt to complete the Harvest." Are these things connected? We think so. So far, Davina has been very against completing the Harvest ritual as it will mean her dying. In theory, she will come back to life (along with the three other teenaged girls who were sacrificed), but that’s a bit risk to take. We think Davina could be convinced to do it — both to keep her powers and to bring BFF Monique back from the dead. We kind of think this is the direction the show has to go in — otherwise, all of the witches’ magic (including Davina’s) will eventually die, and that would be kind of boring. Even more boring than the witchy storyline now.

To take down Klaus

Davina doesn’t really like Klaus, but she hasn’t made any all-out declarations of enemy-ship, either. It looks like that might be about to change, though. In the mid-season finale, Davina fled Klaus (Joseph Morgan) and Marcel’s (Charles Michael Davis) digs to shack up with Cami (Leah Pipes), who knows all about Klaus’s evil deeds. Will these two decide to take down Klaus themselves? Davina has been trying to figure out how to kill an Original, and the promo for the next episode shows Davina saying, “I’ll kill them. All of them.” Is she talking about the Original family? Maybe not, but that Klaus shot does not look good.

To help the werewolves

Right now, the werewolves are kind of the supernatural race out on The Originals. They’re around, but they don’t have much power or prospect — unless they found themselves a powerful ally. In the mid-season finale, Hayley (Phoebe Tonkin) tried to convince Davina to team up. Presumably, part of that alliance will be the protection of Hayley’s werewolf kin. Will Davin decide to trust the pregnant werewolf? She could be a useful spy as she is living under Klaus’s protection — plus, she genuinely seems to hate him, so it’s hard to doubt her dedication to the cause.

What choice do you think Davina will be making? Share your theories in the comments below!

The Originals returns Tuesday, January 14, at 8 p.m. ET on The CW.

Kayti Burt is a contributing writer for Wetpaint Entertainment with a penchant for all things pop culture. Follow her on Twitter and Google+!