It might not be as big of a debate as the whole Delena vs. Stelena debacle, but we do care about who Hayley (Phoebe Tonkin) ends up with on The Originals. So far the little wolf has been impregnated by Klaus (Joseph Morgan) and is in a will-they/won’t-they storyline with her baby daddy’s big brother, Elijah (Daniel Gillies). How scandalous, right?

In a shipper poll conducted by E! Online, fans have spoken out and decisively chosen who they want Hayley to be with — but which Mikaelson did they pick?

A majority of fans, 55 percent, would prefer Hayley and Klaus to settle down and make this little hybrid family work. Perhaps they could do the whole white picket fence and well-manicured lawn thing, but we feel like there’s always going to be some animosity between the two. We get the whole sharing a baby together thing, but can’t they be a modern family?

Only 45 percent of fans prefered Hayley with Elijah. We totally understand that this is a rather unseemly pairing, but have you seen the chemistry they have together?! Hayley might be on Elijah’s naughty list because she went behind his back and helped Sophie (Daniella Pineda) find the bones of Celeste — though the real Celeste (parading about as Sabine) had already gotten to the scene of the crime.

We’re holding out for Halijah because their almost kisses and steamy moments in the pool have been some of our favorite moments of the first season. In fact, earlier this month when Wetpaint asked Viggle users who Hayley should be with, a huge majority were feeling her and Elijah together.

Sounds like the jury is still out on this one!

Who do you think Hayley should be with? Hit the comments and let us know!

Carson Blackwelder is an Assistant Editor at Wetpaint Entertainment. Follow him on Twitter and Google+!