The Secret Circle

It's hard to choose a favorite character on The Secret Circle. There's the feisty little blonde witch, Cassie Blake, or the feisty Amazonian brunette witch, Faye Chamberlain. Not to mention Shelley Hennig as Diana Meade, with her mermaid hair and demure demeanor. The boys are a whole 'nother quandary: which manwitch is the hottest? It's a five-way tie between Jake's I-can't-help-that-I'm-a-witch-hunter smolder, Adam's eyelashes, Nick's (now dead) shirtless body, Ethan's sentimental (and drunken) attachment to fate, and Charles' murderous angst. We're so in love with this show that we tracked down clips from the actors' previous roles. Check 'em out below!

Now a series regular, Chris Zylka is no stranger to playing the heartthrob. Check out his stint as the object of Miley Cyrus's affection in Hannah Montana.

How do we love Phoebe? Oh, let us count the ways: the Australian actress is a huge Taylor Swift fan, a love of both scrunchies and green smoothies, and is obsessed with the '90s. Below, behond Phoebe's star turn as a mermaid:

Adam isn't the only sensitive ladykiller Thomas Dekker has played on television; check out his singing stint on 7th Heaven (R.I.P.).

You know how Diana walks around Chance Harbor like a beauty queen? Yeah, that's because Shelley Hennig is one in real life.

It would be somewhat of an understatement to say Gale has a cult following. If you've seen him in action as Charles Meade, you understand why; no one does conscientious bad boy better than this veteran actor.

Equal parts strong and vulnerable, Cassie Blake is the petite anchor of The Secret Circle. Britt Robertson is only 21 years old, but has a long tenure of playing characters with storied pasts. Here, the Southern-born actress talks about her role in Life Unexpected.