The only thing better than one double-damaged stud? Two double-damaged studs who share the same gene pool that includes floppy hair and six-packs! The CW must be the luckiest network ever because they have the hottest magical brothers on TV, and it's time for two pairs to go bicep-to-bicep.

The Secret Circle is home to Jake (Chris Zylka) and Nick Armstrong (Louis Hunter), a duo of man-witches who lurk in shadows wearing tank tops and chain necklaces. Bad-boy behavior practically oozes out of their pours, and both of them are completely tragic. Oh, and in case you couldn't tell by their last name: Their arms are strong. Of course, Nick's currently six-feet under, but we live in a world of denial where hot men never die.

Then there's Supernatural, where Sam (Jared Padalecki) and Dean Winchester (Jensen Ackles) reside: two dangerously attractive brothers who wander the backwoods of America killing paranormal demons and being extremely angsty while doing so. These boys are plagued by their traumatic past — but instead of talking to a therapist, they bottle up their feelings and wear tons of flannel. Oh, and did we mention how good-looking they are? One might even call them supernaturally hunky....

Which pair of badass bros do you prefer?

 

Can’t get enough of The Secret Circle? Like us on our Facebook page or follow us on Twitter!