Credit: Michael Courtney/The CW ©2011 The CW Network Photo: Diana, Cassie, Melissa, and Faye in Season 1, Episode 14: “Valentine”

There are only a handful of days left until we finally find out the identity of Cassie's (Britt Robertson) secret sibling on The Secret Circle, and the pool has officially been narrowed down to Diana (Shelley Hennig), Faye (Phoebe Tonkin), and Melissa Glaser (Jessica Parker Kennedy). That's right, Blackwell's love child is a girl — which means Cassie didn't accidentally commit incest. Phew!

Faye seems like an obvious choice — she's gloomy, obsessed with dark magic, and her mom had the hots for John Blackwell. But on the other hand, she's terrible at doing solo magic (squib alert!). That leaves Melissa and Diana, both viable options. Diana and Cassie have a sisterly bond that could definitely be blood related, and Melissa had a strange connection to Blackwell while they were mixing herbal tinctures in the clubhouse. 

Each of these ladies has a strong case for why they might be Cassie's sis, but it’s time for you experts to voice an opinion. Who is Cassie's long-lost sister from a mutual mister?

Can’t get enough of The Secret Circle? Like us on our Facebook page or follow us on Twitter!

Credit: YouTube Photo: Secret Circle Extended Preview Video For Season 1, Episode 19, "Crystal": Motorcycle Madness