Melissa and Diana in Season 1, Episode 16: “Lucky”
Cassie catches Blackwell (guest star Joe Lando) sneaking around the abandoned house. After confiding in Adam, he tells her he knows Blackwell was looking for a device to drain witches’ powers and clearly back to his old ways. Faye shows up at Lee’s house to invite him to the school fundraiser, but is taken aback when Eva (guest star Alexia Fast) greets her at the door claiming to be Lee’s girlfriend. Meanwhile, Melissa encourages Diana to date a normal guy and points her in the direction of a new, handsome guy in town (guest star Tim Phillipps). Dawn runs into Blackwell at the school but the reunion isn’t quite what she expected.
Original Air Date: March 15, 2012 at 9 p.m. on The CW!