Credit: ABC Family Photo: Switched at Birth Cast - Season 1

We’ve been in a permanent state of swoon ever since Gilles Marini and his luscious lashes sashayed over to Switched at Birth as Bay’s biological father — but he isn’t the only stud in town!

Let’s not forget about John Kennish — Daphne’s uptight biological pops who’s happily married to Kathryn. Or so we thought ....

Prepare for the shock of a lifetime when a woman named Sarah Lazar announces that she’s pregnant with John’s baber in episode 15, “Expulsion From The Garden Of Eden.” Wait — rewind!

If John’s about to become a baby daddy, that means he either cheated on Kathryn on they’re getting a divorce! Way to fail at the whole “new year’s resolution” thing, Mr. Kennish.

Source: slotat.tripod.com