Credit: Jason Merritt/Getty Images; PacificCoastNews Photo: Shailene Woodley vs. Taylor Momsen: Who Wore It Best?

Although they both play teenagers on television, Secret Life’s Shailene Woodley and Gossip Girl’s Taylor Momsen’s styles couldn’t be more different.

While Shai goes for a mix of comfortable, casual clothes and girly dresses, Taylor wears edgy — and usually ripped or tattered — frocks, including super-short skirts, fishnet tights, and barely-there T-shirts.

But in 2010, they both wore the same gorgeous Alice + Olivia Jessica T-back dress! This sleeveless, draped silk bandage dress hugged at both of their curves and showed off a whole lotta leg!

They wore different colors — with Tay rockin’ the olive green shade on the Gossip Girl set and Shai going for classic black at the 2010 MTV Movie Awards — but they both looked great.

To complete their looks, Taylor went for Donna Karan micro tulle tights in a subtle fishnet pattern and chunky lace-up boots while Shai was bare-legged, wearing Steven by Steve Madden Bevan high-heeled suede ankle boots!

Even though both gals looked great, who wore the Alice + Olivia bandage dress best? Vote below!