Which Vampire Diaries Star Was a Toddler-Aged Virgin Mary?

Phoebe Tonkin (Hayley) was in Australia for the spooky holiday, but on October 31, she still tweeted a picture of herself in costume — albeit from many years ago. The brunette beauty was quite young in this photo, and she wrote, “From the archives: Me as the Virgin Mary.” Probably more appropriate for Christmas than Halloween, but cute as heck nonetheless!