Yes, No, Maybe So? 8 Male Celebs Who Look Like They Wear Guyliner (PHOTOS)

YES: American Idol Season 7 winner David Cook let the rock world know he’d arrived when he showed up to his first-ever American Music Awards donning some pretty obvious guyliner. Though he rarely wears it off the stage, at least one fan has begged him to take a lighter hand with the kohl. In a open letter on Cook’s website, she says: “Stop wearing as much eye makeup as me. I really think RuPaul has that covered, kthnx.”