Credit: Kevin Winter (Getty)/Mayer RCF(Splash)

Watch out, Christina Aguilera fans! It looks like The Vampire Diaries star Kat Graham has been wandering in the The Voice coach’s closet! During the New York City Mercedes Benz fashion week in, Kat worked this star-spangled corset by The Blonds at the designer’s spring 2014 runway show (right). Xtina, however, wore the same starry corset almost a year before during her performance at the 2012 American Music Awards (left).

So, who do we think wore it best?

No offense, Kat, but we think Xtina won this one. The “Beautiful” singer nailed this look by pulling the corset together with sparkly boy-shorts, fishnet stockings, and knee-high leather boots (not shown). While the corset is brought entirely to the forefront in Kat’s look, her pulled back hair, and open-toed heels (not shown) reveals more skin, which draws our eyes to the 24-year-old actress’s lovely (yet overexposed) frame.

A corset that daring requires a little more edge in the overall look, which Christina (not surprisingly) provided.

Who you you guys think worked the starry corset best — Christina or Kat? Sound off in the comments below!

Afiya Augustine is an associate editor at Wetpaint Entertainment. Follow her on Google+!