On May 7, Team Shakira’s Sasha Allen closed out the night on The Voice 2013 with an epic performance of The Beatles’ “Oh! Darling.” The number solidified her spot as one of this season’s front runners, but it also reminded us of Season 2 Team Cee Lo Green finalist, Juliet Simms.

Gritty rocker Juliet sang the song for her blind audition in February 2012 and then went on to make it to second place on the show. Juliet’s performance earned her a three-chair turn and a spot on Team Cee Lo.

Now she’s recording an album under Cee Lo’s management and performing on The Voice’s live results show tonight (May 8) with her former coach.

But when it comes to this Beatles cover, which singer gave the best performance? Watch the clips and tell us what you think below! 

Credit: NBC Photo: Watch Juliet Simms Sing ''Oh! Darling'' by The Beatles on The Voice 2012 Premiere, February 5