Credit: Tyler Golden/NBC) Photo: Terry McDermott and Casey Muessigmann Sing Their Hearts Out

Team Blake members Casey Muessigmann and Terry McDermott were tasked with singing Kansas’s “Carry on Wayward Son” during the first night of battle rounds. After both men met with mentor Michael Buble, they rehearsed together before taking the stage.

When the duet was done, even the other judges were singing Casey and Terry’s praises, but ultimately Blake decided that Terry won the battle round. Unfortunately for Casey, none of the other judges attempted to snag him for their team.

Did Blake make the right choice? Tell us below!