Blake Shelton said he had been a fan of James's from the beginning, but the performance "just kind of laid there for me."
Christina Aguilera concurred. "I would have wanted something a little different," while Adam Levine "loved it a lot."
Coach Cee Lo said he enjoyed the song. "Your voice is so genuine and so sweet, so soft spoken," he said, noting that the women in the audience love him.
What did you think of James's performance?
B. Just OK.
Tell us your answer on Facebook!