Mathai, a contestant on Team Adam Levine, took the stage on The Voice Season 2 performance show on April 9, 2012 to sing "Ordinary People" by John Legend
Christina Aguilera liked her voice, but added, "it was a little lounge-y for me. If you make it past this point, I’d like to see you pick it up."
Blake Shelton loved Mathai's confidence, while Adam called her performance "magical."
"You have one of the most unique voices in the competition," he declared.
What did you think of Mathai's performance?
B. Just OK.
Tell us your answer on Facebook!