Who Wore It Best: Christina Aguilera vs. Kristen Stewart in Black Lace Valentino

The pop diva versus the vampire? That sounds like a bad TV show idea (don’t get any ideas producers), but when we saw these photos of The Voice’s Christina Aguilera and Twilight’s Kristen Stewart wearing the same Valentino dress, we knew there was a battle brewing.

No, not a battle like the one between the werewolves and the vampires, but rather a fashion face-off!

Kristen wore the black lace-covered minidress first at the New York City screening of her film Welcome to the Rileys in October 2010. Then, Christina appeared in the frock at the Mary J. Blige Honors Concert in May 2011.

The Snow White and the Huntsman star ditched her Chuck Taylors for some stilettos, and the “Beautiful” singer paired the dress with some black peep-toe pumps.

Christina let her blond locks flow, while Kristen swept up her hair, but both ladies opted for a bold red lip.

But who wore it best — the angsty actress with a cult following or the sultry Voice judge with host of Grammys? Vote below!