Who Wore It Best: The Voice’s Christina Aguilera vs. Harry Potter’s Bonnie Wright in Schoolgirl Cardigan

One is a major pop diva and the other is a powerful witch with the key to Harry Potter’s heart, but who is the bigger fashionista?

HP actress Bonnie Wright first wore the Comme Des Garcons Play cardigan at a Japanese press conference for Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 1 on November 18, 2010.

Then, Christina Aguilera wore the same cardigan on The Voice during an elimination show on April 10, 2012. On the singer’s website, Xtina’s makeup artist Jake Bailey said, “Christina’s schoolgirl look was the perfect mix of sweet and sexy.”

The cardigan has also been worn by Lena Dunham of HBO’s Girls and even Max Greenfield from New Girl!

But between Bonnie and Christina, who wore the cardigan best? The pop singer going for a sexy schoolgirl look or the Hogwarts schoolgirl promoting her magical film? Vote below!