Credit: MTV Photo: Jeremy Guthrie on MTV2's Off the Bat from the MLB Fan Cave

Which MLB pitcher has a soft spot for Juan Pablo Galavis and The Bachelor franchise? (Hint: he’s a Royal!) You’re about to find out.

MTV2’s new series Off the Bat From the MLB Fan Cave takes your favorite Major League Baseball players off the field and gives you the scoop on what they’re really out of their uniforms. Its latest segment — DVR Confessions — allows the players to share their guilty TV pleasures, and we have to admit: these fellas really do have a passion for reality TV. It looks like we’re not the only ones who get sucked into Keeping Up With the Kardashians marathons on E!.

Find out which MLB pros are hooked on The Bachelor, The Real Housewives of Beverly Hills, and more in the clip below.

Catch all-new episodes of Off The Bat From The MLB Fan Cave on Tuesdays at 11 p.m. ET on MTV2.

Crystal Bell is an editor at Wetpaint Entertainment and our resident fangirl for all things The Vampire Diaries. Follow her on Twitter and Google+!