Credit: © Steve Wilkie for BBC America

Bad news, Orphan Black fans — one of our favorite characters is about to have a rather chilling encounter with a familiar figure in the next episode. And no, we’re not talking about Sarah (Tatiana Maslany) chained to a shower head while her twin, Helena (also Tatiana) — previously thought dead — approaches with a bloody knife. We’re talking about Felix (Jordan Gavaris) held at gunpoint by Paul (Dylan Bruce).

In this sneak peek of Season 2, Episode 5: “Ipsa Scientia Potestas Est” (translation: “Knowledge Is Power”), Sarah’s loveable foster brother finds himself in the company of Paul, one-time monitor to the late Beth Childs and occasional sex monkey to Sarah Manning. However, we’re not sure we’re loving this side of Paul (our favorite side is his backside, btw — and we’re not alone on that matter).

First off, it seems like Paul knows Felix was at Cal’s (Michael Huisman) cabin, which probably means he knows where Sarah and Kira are. And it also seems Paul is very, very invested in finding out their whereabouts now — enough to pin Fe down and point a gun at his head as he screams in terror.

Watch the clip here but be warned — it’s a little terrifying. The biggest question we have (you know, other than whether Felix will be OK), is whether Paul’s intensity is about hunting Sarah down or keeping her safe. After all, our confidence in Cal being a stand-up guy is definitely pretty shaky. But at this point, that’s true of at least half the characters on the show!