When Kat Graham stepped out for the 2013 BET Awards on Sunday, June 30, the Vampire Diaries star had fans doing a double take. The actress and musician looked stunning in a strappy black Versace frock from the 1990s — but it wasn’t the first time that weekend we’d seen a similar vintage look.

Just one day earlier, Miley Cyrus wore a nearly identical version of the dress when she took to the iHeartRadio Ultimate Pool Party in Miami Beach.

Kat — who recently debuted her new electro-pop hit “Power” — opted for a glamorous take on the frock. With bouncy waves and bold red lips, Kat paid homage to the brand’s signature style by adding gold Versace earrings and matching satin boots.

Miley, on the other hand, went for a decidedly punk-inspired look. The “We Can’t Stop” singer played up her svelte figure in the mini bondage number, which she paired with an exaggerated pompadour and sharp red nails.

Both trendsetters both their own unique spins on the dress, but we can’t help but ask: Kat Graham or Miley Cyrus — who wore it best?