Do you watch Teen Wolf? Well, you should! There are lizards that secrete paralyzing goo. Those crazy shape-shifters. But ever since the scaly monster showed up, we started to wonder if Vampire Diaries needs more supernaturals that go bump in the night.

Right now, Mystic Falls boasts werewolves, witches, hybrids, and vampires. Would introducing a new beast upset the balance, or would it just add a little more spice to the magical melting pot that is Mystic Falls? We’re not gonna lie, cat people would be cool, but we’re really holding out hope that Elena (Nina Dobrev) will start riding unicorns.

What? Unicorns are magic.