Could it be? Did Paul Wesley (Stefan) and long-term girlfriend Torrey DeVitto of Pretty Little Liars finally tie the knot?

According to Life & Style, they did! Reportedly, the couple recently took their three-year-long relationship to the next level in “a secret ceremony in NYC,” and apparently, “since then Torrey has been spotted wearing a canary yellow diamond and a wedding band on the set of Pretty Little Liars.” But us eagle eyes at Wetpaint know that Torrey has actually been wearing the ring for some time now. (What? Don’t call us stalkers!)

We don’t know whether to believe this one (why would the couple who have already publicly declared their love want to hide a bee-yoo-tee-ful marriage?), but Wesley did refer to Torrey as “his wife” back in 2010, according to Hollywood Life. Maybe that Freudian slip actually had some truth behind it!

Sources: Hollywood Life, Life & Style