‘Tis the season for giving, and as all Vampire Diaries fans can attest there’s one gift that trumps them all—hot supernatural creatures. To be fair, though, when you live in a town like Mystic Falls, even the plain old humans are hot.

The question, then, is this: Which cast member from the show would you most want to unwrap as a present on Christmas morning? (Sure, this may sound silly, but we’re big believers in Santa, and we’ve been super nice this year.)

We’ve got the list of eligible stocking stuffers below, all you have to do is vote and we’ll crown the Best Supernatural Holiday Gift winner!