What the what? We thought for sure Ian Somerhalder (Damon Salvatore) and Paul Wesley (Stefan Salvatore) could only lose the 2013 People’s Choice Award for Favorite Dramatic TV Actor to each other and that Nina Dobrev (Elena Gilbert) had Favorite Dramatic TV Actress locked up. Unfortunately, we were wrong and are now in serious debt to our bookie. 

Castle’s Nathan Fillion nabbed the Dramatic TV Actor award, while Ellen Pompeo of Grey’s Anatomy beat out Nina. As if that weren’t enough bad news, Vampire Diaries lost the Favorite Sci-Fi/Fantasy TV Show award and Favorite TV Fan Following to Supernatural. What is even happening?!

Even Paul’s castmate was upset. “Paul = robbed,” tweeted Daniel Gillies (Elijah).

They all were, Daniel. They all were.