Credit: Quantrell Colbert/The CW Photo: Caroline Is Pensive in The Vampire Diaries Season 3, Episode 9, “Homecoming”


“Diamonds or charms? Diamonds or charms?” That’s pretty much the question Caroline Forbes (Candice Accola) will be asking herself every morning from now on. The blonde vampire was gifted with a sweet charm bracelet from new hybrid Tyler (Michael Trevino) and a sparkly diamond-encrusted one courtesy of Original Klaus (Joseph Morgan). Both are nice, but the dudes who gave them to her have issues. Tyler bit her and nearly killed her, and Klaus told Tyler to do so. One is moody and sired, the other a mass murderer. How to choose…