Not long after seeing Jeremy (Steven R. McQueen) get wood outside the cabin in Episode 9 of Season 4 of the Vampire Diaries, we realized that he might also be getting wood — so to speak — for Bonnie (Kat Graham).

Okay, we’ll stop with the Jeremy-shirtless-chopping-wood-then-getting-wood jokes. But in all seriousness, there seemed to be a spark big enough to light a fire between the two former loves.

For now, that spark seems solely to serve the purpose of keeping Jeremy from killing Elena (Nina Dobrev). Because, according to Damon’s (Ian Somerhalder) theory, if Jer’s able to funnel his emotions into something else—or someone that he loves—that can distract him from the overwhelming urge to stab any and all vampires.

Thus, we have a vampire hunter who has to focus intensely on a witch. Already we’ve seen the two become close again—but we can’t be sure if Bonnie is just playing along for the sake of Elena or if these advances are welcomed.

What we’d like to see is a Beremy reunion, especially since we don’t like the way Professor Shane has gotten so close to our gal-pal witch. So, that’s what we’ll be rooting for in the back half of Season 4 of Vampire Diaries: Beremy 4 Evah!

Care to disagree with this shippage? Tell us below!