Caution! Potential Spoilers for Vampire Diaries Season 4, Episode 10, “After School Special.” 

Ever since we saw this sneak peek clip of Vampire Diaries Season 4, Episode 10, “After School Special,” we’ve just wanted to hide under the covers with a tube of cookie dough and a worry stone. Rebekah (Claire Holt), what have you done with Caroline (Candice Accola)?!

Normally, we’d say nothing fatal could happen to the non-Original blond. Torture? Sure. A stake to the heart? No way. But now we’re not so sure.

In the clip, Caroline wanders the halls of Mystic Falls High, ready to stake Bex. Instead, the Original sis finds Stefan (Paul Wesley). “I hope you’re not waiting for Caroline to show up and stake me,” she tells him. “Because I already found her.”

Menacing! But Caroline’s probably fine, right? Well, there are two reasons to worry: One, TVLine spoiled that the overachieving cheerleader might die, and two, Caroline isn’t in the next two synopses.

Add to that the fact that a werewolf-version of Tyler (Michael Trevino) is on the loose, and it means that any number of Mystic Falls dangers could do-in Caroline.

Want to borrow our worry stone?

Credit: TV Guide Photo: Vampire Diaries Spoiler Video For Season 4, Episode 10: What Does Rebekah Want?