Credit: Ryan Turgeon and Thelonius/Splash News Photo: Ian Somerhalder and Nina Dobrev Arrive at the 2012 MET Ball After-Party

Clear some space on your DVR, because Vampire Diaries stars Nina Dobrev (Elena Gilbert) and Ian Somerhalder (Damon Salvatore) are making the late-night talk show rounds! Ian is heading to Chelsea Lately, while Nina will show up on Conan O’Brien.

The conundrum? Both shows are airing on Wednesday, May 9 at 11 p.m. Chelsea Lately is on E!, while TBS broadcasts Conan. The horror! So who will watch live, and who will you DVR? Now we know what Elena feels like!

Sources: E!, Team Coco