The first time we met The Vampire DiariesJeremy Gilbert (Steven R. McQueen), he was nothing but an emo teen with a little drug problem, a bit of an attitude problem, and a big hair problem. But through the years, Jer has changed quite a bit. He cut his hair and won Bonnie’s (Kat Graham) heart in Season 2, but it wasn’t until recently that he made the final transition from attractive to full-blown hottie. And what was it that pushed him over the super sexy edge?

Hello, Mr. Vampire Hunter. Being one of The Five has changed Jeremy in all the right ways — physically that is. Between his bulging biceps, his wardrobe (cough, wife beaters), and his evil stare (is it weird that we love it?), Jeremy Gilbert is officially one hot piece of meat. We don’t know about you guys, but we’d pick the tattooed, wood-chopping version of Jer over the shy, pot-smoking version any day.

Which version of Elena’s (Nina Dobrev) younger brother do you prefer: Season 1 Jer, Bonnie’s Jer, or this new hunter version?

Samantha Highfill is a contributing writer to Wetpaint Entertainment. Follow her on Twitter at @samhighfill.