Credit: Annette Brown/The CW © 2011 The CW Network, LLC Photo: Stefan Is Crazed in Season 2, Episode 15: "The Dinner Party"

Our therapist is a little concerned about our bad boy complex. We didn’t think it was such a problem, but now that the return of the ripper, a.k.a. Evil Stefan, has occurred on The Vampire Diaries, we starting to think maybe the doc has a point. There’s no denying tender-hearted Stefan, with his super-Elena-protecting skills and diarist tendencies, is sexy. But Evil Stefan? Well, that’s a whole different story. Are you with us on this, or do you think we’re hallucinating worse than a vampire three days into an infected werewolf bite? Let us know!