Everyone knows that Paul Wesley has had a roller coaster ride in the romance department lately. The Vampire Diaries star just split from wife Torrey DeVitto and has all but confirmed that he’s dating Originals star Phoebe Tonkin. But who was Paul getting cozy with almost a decade ago, back in 2004?

You might not know that Paul was staying in the supernatural genre when he agreed to go out with a special someone way back when. The 31-year-old actor was linked to one of the lovely ladies from The WB’s hit witch drama Charmed.

During last Thursday’s all-new episode of The Vampire Diaries, Wetpaint asked Viggle users which magical lady — either Rose McGowan, Holly Marie Combs, or Marnette Patterson — was lucky enough to say she dated the hunky actor.

Care to test your knowledge of The Vampire Diaries with other questions about the hit show? Download Viggle now!

A staggering 56 percent of Viggle users incorrectly guessed that Paul had dated the lovely Rose McGowan, who played Paige Matthews on Charmed. A solid 24 percent of Viggle users also wrongly guessed that Paul had dated Holly Marie Combs, who played Piper Halliwell on the beloved show. Only 20 percent of Viggle users correctly picked Marnette Patterson as the girl who Paul had dated.

Paul dated Marnette from 2004 to 2005 and appeared in Cloud 9 with her in 2006 — just check out this pic of them on the set in 2004 (weird to see a blond Paul, right?). Sure, Marnette only appeared in eight episodes of Charmed in Season 8, but she did play Christy Jenkins, elder sister to Kaley Cuoco’s Billie Jenkins (aka one half of “The Ultimate Power”). That’s a pretty big deal!

Do you want to test your TV knowledge? Not only is it easy, but you also get rewarded just for watching your favorite shows! All you have to do is download the Viggle app, get watching, and check into Viggle LIVE!

Carson Blackwelder is an Associate Editor at Wetpaint Entertainment. Follow him on Twitter and Google+!