We know Spencer has been hiding a huge secret on Pretty Little Liars, and while we’re not 100 percent sure what it is yet, we do have a hunch it has something to do with the night Ali disappeared. Spencer and Ali has a confrontation the night the latter disappeared, but is it possible it escalated into something more? Could Spencer actually be the one responsible for helping Ali fake her death?

Wetpaint Entertainment recently posed the question to Viggle LIVE! users and a whopping 93 percent thought there was no way Spencer could have helped Ali fake her death. Meanwhile, only seven percent of Viggle users thought we were onto something.

Want to play along and get rewarded for loving Pretty Little Liars? Download the FREE Viggle App now!


OK, so we’ll admit our theory doesn’t quite make a lot of sense. If Spencer did help Ali fake her death, then why wouldn’t Ali come to her in Season 4? Instead, it looks like Ali is scared of Spencer, which makes us believe that something explosive happened between the two frenemies the night Ali disappeared — something a bit more physical. Could Spencer have hurt Ali that night?  

Until we get a straight answer from Marlene King & Co., we highly suggest you head over to Viggle, download the app, and then go back to watching TV — while earning points toward cool stuff!