Credit: Frederick M. Brown/Getty Images Photo: Lauren Cohan in North Hollywood, California on February 5, 2013

Lauren Cohan (Maggie Greene) had the pleasure of stopping by the Bravo Clubhouse on March 5 for an appearance on Watch What Happens Live, and because it was her first time on the late night chat fest, host Andy Cohen challenged her to a game of Plead the Fifth. Basically, Andy asks three tough questions and you can pass on answering one of them, but then you must answer the remaining two no matter what.

For Lauren, Andy started off with a doozy: Who do you want to see get bit next? “Out of everybody?” Lauren nervously inquired. “Oh my gosh…” Her fellow guest for the night, Flipping Out star Jeff Lewis offered up Carl Grimes (Chandler Riggs), but Lauren wasn’t biting. Get it?!

Finally she found a way around Andy’s tough query.“Any of the newbies, I don’t know them yet,” she reasoned. “I don’t know them yet so I haven’t developed a love.”

For her final question Andy wondered which living cast member smells most like a zombie. It took Lauren a second but then she came back with “Oh my god, Daryl!” We kind of imagined that would be the case, but we’re glad we had Lauren confirm it for us. Plus, it’s really hot on that Atlanta set, we’re pretty sure no one smells too great.

Lauren’s middle question was a game of Marry, Shag, Kill with TWD characters, but you’ll have to watch the clip below to see how that one played out. Trust us when we say it’ll be worth your while!

The Walking Dead Season 4 airs Sundays at 9 p.m. ET on AMC.