As the final song of the evening, Angie Miller performed "Cry Me A River" by Julie London for her "one hit wonder" choice.
Mariah Carey says she feels like Angie has been holding out on them with some of the notes she hit with that song. Beautiful, talent galore, she doesn’t know what else to say. Keith says “mystical and celestially powerful” because they told him to use “only three words” but Nicki points out that is actually four.
Nicki Minaj says tonight was Angie’s night and she was blowing the wigs off people or something... Randy says his two words are “yo, yo” — but not really, he thinks Angie had the best performance of the night and she’s (groan) in it to win it.