Who Is Going Home After the American Idol 2012 Top 5 Performed on May 2, 2012?
It was a British pop invasion on American Idol when the Top 5 performed on May 2. They took on pop songs from across the pond — but does that mean BritHollie Cavanagh won the night? After everyone sang their ‘60s songs, the judges named her among their favorites, while completely ignoring Phillip Phillips and Jessica Sanchez. Do you agree with them, or is someone else going home?