But it wasn’t all praise and kudos for everyone. Lazaro Arbos, who sang “In My Life,” came under the scrutiny of the judges for whatRandy Jackson thought was a pitchy performance, a surprise since he’s been a fan favorite for a while now. Similarly,Paul Jolley got some flack for his version of “Eleanor Rigby,” whichNicki Minaj considered to be a bland and safe choice for the singer.
But which American Idol Top 9 contestant do you think deserves to go home tomorrow? Vote in our poll below and let us know!