In The X Factor Season, 2 Episode 8, the second day of bootcamp pit two huge talents against one another: Jennel Garcia and Tara Simon. The two singers debated which kind of song to perform — big and showy, or soft and subtle — ultimately deciding on the quiet, yet sentimental “Landslide” by Fleetwood Mac.

But it seemed like Tara took the opportunity to show off her voice to the judges nevertheless, while Jennel struggled to make the song her own.

So it must be asked: Did Tara intentionally choose a song she could outperform or can Tara just not help herself? Weigh in below!

Want more X Factor goodness? Like us on Facebook or follow us on Twitter!

Credit: Youtube Photo: Watch Jennel Garcia and Tara Simon Sing Fleetwood Mac’s "Landslide" During X Factor 2012 Bootcamp on October 4 (VIDEO)