Credit: The X Factor's Official Site Photo: Melanie Amaro Gets Goofy With a Bird on December 13, 2011

By now, you've seen Melanie Amaro's Pepsi commercial. We thought it was a fun, creative romp! That's right, a romp! But what about YOU? How did YOU feel about the whole thing? Was it weird seeing her with Elton John, or was it just right? Did they let her sing enough? Was that the right song for her? You can analyze it six ways to Superbowl Sunday, OR you can vote in our poll! Vote!